Files
VoiceStudio/tests/test_media_tool_missing.py
Palash Debnath 73ebd6518d fix(errors): six failures that reached users as raw text (#1262, #1256, #1251, #1247, #1257, #1254) (#1264)
* fix(errors): four failures that reached users as raw OS text (#1262, #1256, #1251, #1252)

#1262 — a voice profile named in any non-latin-1 script 500'd every download
endpoint with "'latin-1' codec can't encode characters in position 22-25".
`attachment; filename="` is exactly 22 characters, so those were the first
four characters of the user's own name. The sanitisers in front of the header
filtered with str.isalnum(), which is True for every alphabetic script — they
stripped punctuation and passed exactly what breaks the header. Ten sites, one
RFC 6266 builder, plus a guard so an eleventh can't be hand-written.

#1256 — a synth died on FileNotFoundError: 'ffprobe' and was reported as "an
error OmniVoice doesn't recognize", on a Mac where the app's own ffprobe was
resolvable the whole time. Our call sites pass explicit paths; a dependency
shelling out by bare name does not. The resolved directories are now published
on PATH, and the failure is classified either way.

#1251 — "The paging file is too small" reached the user as a bare 500. It was
already counted as an OOM, but that remedy (close apps, lighter engine) is
wrong on a 32 GB machine — the fix is a Windows setting, and the hint now says
which. Matched on the code in both the Python and Rust spellings.

#1252/#1253 — deleting a dub mid-import crashed it with `ingest: 'mgw39lx3'`:
str(KeyError) is the repr of the key. The pipeline blind-subscripted a job that
DELETE /dub/history/{id} had popped minutes earlier. It now stops quietly, and
no exception whose str() is a bare value can present itself that way again.

* fix(engines): Unload 400'd, a wrong language said nothing, DRM was retried by hand (#1247, #1257, #1254)

#1247 — list_loaded() advertises in-process engines as `engine:<id>` with
"unloadable": true, but unload() only ever handled tts/diarization/sidecars.
The panel was rendering a button for ids the dispatcher rejected. The engines
already implement unload(); only the routing was missing. The contract test
written for it immediately found a second instance — `capture-asr`, listed the
same way with no branch either — which is why it enumerates the listing rather
than hard-coding ids.

#1257 — MLXAudioBackend.supported_languages() returns ["multi"] on the stated
assumption that "each engine silently ignores languages it doesn't know". It
doesn't; the library raises. So the picker offers all 646 languages and the
rejection arrived as a bare list of 23 codes, naming neither the engine nor the
way out. Enumerating each model's real language set would be a brittle map that
goes stale every engine update — name the engine and the fix instead.

#1254 — reported as intermittent: the same URL failed as DRM-protected, then
succeeded on retry. Real DRM doesn't lapse; the player client varies. That is
the same shape as the 403 case which already escalates through
_YT_PLAYER_CLIENTS, so DRM now routes into it. If every client still refuses,
the failure is classified instead of arriving as a raw yt-dlp line.

* fix(review): close the delete race, narrow the tool match, sanitize the fallback

Greptile P1 + CodeRabbit Major — verified real, and mine: splitting merge from
save left a window where a delete lands between them, so the pending save
UPSERTs the row straight back and a dub the user deleted reappears. Now one
atomic step under _dub_jobs_lock, with both delete endpoints purging rows and
memory under that same lock. That also fixed DELETE /dub/history, which
deleted every row but evicted nothing — an in-flight job survived 'clear
history' outright and re-saved itself on completion.

CodeRabbit Minor (#1256): the media-tool match accepted any message ending in
'ffmpeg'/'ffprobe', so a missing FILE at /tmp/ffmpeg got the 'repair your
media engine' remedy. Now requires the name unquoted-and-unqualified.

CodeRabbit Major (#1262): `fallback` reached the header verbatim whenever the
real name folded away entirely, walking past every guard the name goes
through. Folded like the name.

CodeRabbit Major (#1256): the PATH log printed resolved directories, and a
user-set FFMPEG_PATH sits under their home. Logs a count now.

CodeRabbit Minor (#1262): the subtitle-route assertion also passed against the
pre-fix header; it now asserts filename*= too.

Skipped: 'Highlights bullets must end with (#N)'. CLAUDE.md scopes that to the
### subsections; none of the seven pre-existing highlights carry refs, and
tests/test_changelog_style.py encodes the rule already.

* fix(review): the remaining unlocked save paths, an over-broad signature, two weak tests

Greptile P1 — the mid-pipeline put_job + save_job pairs were still unlocked, so
a clear-history landing between them left a ghost row behind the purge. Both go
through put_and_save_job now; only the final completion gate decides whether a
withdrawn job's work is kept.

CodeRabbit Major (#1257) — 'unsupported language' as a bare prefix also matches
'Unsupported language model configuration', handing a model/config failure
engine-switch advice it has no use for. The loose wordings now require the
rejected thing to be a code or to end there.

CodeRabbit Major (#1257) — the OOM test asserted on SOURCE TEXT, which passes
even if the call is unreachable or its result discarded; #1224 taught this same
lesson on this codebase. Both it and the language rewrite now drive the real
_run_backend_inference with a raising backend.

CodeRabbit Minor (#1257) — 'or "engine" in message' always passed, since the
production template contains the word. Asserts the resolved class name now.

CodeRabbit Major (#1252) — the delete-race test deleted the job BEFORE the
merge, which only re-tested the absent case and would pass with the two steps
still split. It now interleaves a real second thread against a slow save.

CodeRabbit Major (#1256) — a hardcoded /tmp literal trips Ruff S108; built from
tmp_path instead.

* fix(review): a withdrawal must survive the job's first write

CodeRabbit Major — the concern is real, though its suggested fix (gate the
checkpoint on the job already existing) would break creation: an ingest's FIRST
persistence is what creates the entry, so that gate would never pass.

The actual defect is that dict membership cannot express 'withdrawn'. An absent
key means 'not written yet' for a new job and 'deleted' for an established one
— two opposite instructions from one signal. So a clear-history arriving before
the first checkpoint was silently undone by that checkpoint recreating the row,
and the run then persisted its result into history the user had just cleared.

Tombstone it explicitly: the ingest declares itself in flight, a purge marks any
in-flight id withdrawn, and both write paths refuse a withdrawn id. Released in
, so it's bounded by concurrent ingests and can't poison a later run
that reuses the id.

That also fixed clear-history properly: a job with no row yet appears in no id
list, so only an in-flight sweep can catch it.

CodeRabbit Minor — my race test waited on an event that could not be set while
the save held the lock, so it burned its full 2s timeout every run and
synchronised nothing. It now waits for the purge thread to REACH the purge.

* test(dub): the race test was not testing the race

Caught by verifying fail-before rather than trusting the test: splitting merge
from save — the exact resurrection bug — passed all 22 tests.

The assertions checked WHAT happened (the save ran, the row was deleted, the
job left memory) but never WHEN. A save landing after the delete is
indistinguishable from one landing before if you only assert that both
occurred — and 'after' is precisely the resurrection.

Now recorded and asserted as an order. With merge+save atomic the purge cannot
start until the save finishes, so the sequence is always save-then-delete;
split them and it fails with ['delete', 'save'].

That is the second time this test needed rewriting: v1 deleted the job before
the merge and only re-checked the absent case, v2 interleaved a real thread but
asserted the wrong thing. Both looked like tests.

Also documents why the DB write sits inside the lock (atomicity beats a rare
5 s sqlite busy-timeout stall) and that no locked region calls another, so the
non-reentrant lock cannot deadlock — verified by walking every locked region.

* fix(dub): gate the withdrawal at save_job, not at its callers

Greptile P1 — and the same class I'd already fixed, unfixed elsewhere. The
withdrawal check sat in the two ingest helpers, but eight direct save_job call
sites across dub generate / translate / export / core bypass those entirely.
Deleting a dub mid-RENDER therefore still resurrected it, which is at least as
likely as deleting mid-import.

Moved the gate into save_job itself: one choke point, every caller inherits it,
and the ninth cannot forget. That needs a re-entrant lock, since the atomic
helpers call save_job while already holding it — a plain Lock would deadlock
the backend, so a test pins the lock type and another exercises the nested path.

Verified fail-before: removing the gate fails the new test.

* fix(dub): the withdrawal only covered ingests, so it covered almost nothing

Caught by testing the reported scenario directly instead of trusting a green
suite: CI passed, 26 tests passed, and a dub deleted during a RENDER was still
resurrected.

The tombstone was scoped to in-flight ingests. But a dub is imported once and
rendered many times, so the realistic delete lands during a render — long after
its ingest ended — and end_ingest was CLEARING the tombstone at exactly that
point. The rare case was protected and the common one left open.

Now scoped to deletions, not ingests. Kept in a bounded LRU rather than cleared
on completion, because there is no moment at which a delete stops mattering:
any operation still holding that job can persist it. Re-importing an id is the
only thing that legitimately revives it.

Verified fail-before: the previous scoping fails three of the new tests.

* refactor: move the dub delete-resurrection fix to its own PR (#1270)

The six fixes left here are independent error-message changes that needed no
corrections. The dub concurrency change needed five rounds, each finding
something real in work that was already reviewed, tested and CI-green — the
last of them being that the fix did not fix the reported case at all.

Riding a release on that record is a bad trade, so it ships separately as
#1270. This branch keeps #1262, #1256, #1251, #1247, #1257 and #1254; the
KeyError message half goes with the dub PR, since it is that issue's other
half.
2026-07-26 12:39:29 -07:00

202 lines
7.9 KiB
Python

"""#1256: a synth failed with a raw `FileNotFoundError: … 'ffprobe'`.
The reporter's toast, on a Mac with the app's own ffprobe sitting on disk:
Couldn't synthesize audio. … Underlying error: RuntimeError: TTS engine
stopped mid-generation with an error OmniVoice doesn't recognize. Retry
once; if it keeps failing, please report it with the full trace.
Underlying error: FileNotFoundError: [Errno 2] No such file or directory:
'ffprobe'
Two separate defects, fixed here as two halves:
1. **It happened at all.** Every OmniVoice call site resolves ffmpeg/ffprobe
explicitly (`find_ffprobe()`), which is why a bundled sidecar that was never
on ``PATH`` works for us. Our dependencies get no such courtesy — one that
shells out to ``ffprobe`` by bare name finds nothing. Publishing the
resolved directories on ``PATH`` fixes every such dependency at once.
2. **It was illegible.** "an error OmniVoice doesn't recognize" is what the
generic engine wrapper says when `classify()` returns "" — and it did,
because nothing matched a missing media binary. It now names the class and
points at Settings → Audio tools.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
import os
import pytest
from core.failure import build_failure, classify
from services import ffmpeg_utils
# ── the failure is now classified ────────────────────────────────────────
def test_the_reporters_error_is_classified():
assert classify("[Errno 2] No such file or directory: 'ffprobe'") == "MEDIA_TOOL_MISSING"
@pytest.mark.parametrize(
"reason",
[
# As it arrives wrapped by the engine's generic handler.
"FileNotFoundError: [Errno 2] No such file or directory: 'ffprobe'",
"[Errno 2] No such file or directory: 'ffmpeg'",
# subprocess on Windows words it differently.
"[WinError 2] The system cannot find the file specified: 'ffmpeg'",
'[Errno 2] No such file or directory: "ffprobe"',
],
)
def test_every_wording_of_the_missing_binary_is_classified(reason):
assert classify(reason) == "MEDIA_TOOL_MISSING"
def test_the_hint_names_the_repair_and_is_actionable():
failure = build_failure(
FileNotFoundError(2, "No such file or directory", "ffprobe"),
stage="generate",
)
assert failure["error_class"] == "FileNotFoundError"
hint = failure.get("hint") or ""
assert "Audio tools" in hint, "the user needs the panel that fixes it"
assert "ffmpeg" in hint.lower()
def test_a_missing_INPUT_file_is_not_handed_the_media_engine_remedy():
"""The narrow half of the match. ffmpeg reporting that its *input* is
missing is an entirely different problem — telling that user to reinstall
the media engine sends them the wrong way."""
assert classify(
"ffmpeg failed: [Errno 2] No such file or directory: '/tmp/chunk_7.wav'"
) != "MEDIA_TOOL_MISSING"
assert classify(
"No such file or directory: '/Users/x/Movies/my-ffmpeg-export.mp4'"
) != "MEDIA_TOOL_MISSING"
def test_unrelated_errno_2_failures_keep_their_own_class():
"""The rule runs before the generic errno-2 handling, so it must not
swallow the classes that were already correct."""
assert classify("No module named 'omnivoice'") == "BROKEN_VENV"
assert classify(
"does not appear to have a file named model.safetensors"
) == "MODEL_CACHE_CORRUPT"
# ── and it is prevented in the first place ───────────────────────────────
def test_the_resolved_binaries_are_published_on_PATH(monkeypatch, tmp_path):
"""The half that stops the failure happening: a dependency that shells out
by bare name must find what `find_ffprobe()` already resolved."""
bin_dir = tmp_path / "media"
bin_dir.mkdir()
ffmpeg = bin_dir / "ffmpeg"
ffprobe = bin_dir / "ffprobe"
ffmpeg.write_text("")
ffprobe.write_text("")
monkeypatch.setattr(ffmpeg_utils, "find_ffmpeg", lambda: str(ffmpeg))
monkeypatch.setattr(ffmpeg_utils, "find_ffprobe", lambda: str(ffprobe))
monkeypatch.setenv("PATH", "/usr/bin")
added = ffmpeg_utils.ensure_media_tools_on_path()
assert added == [str(bin_dir)]
assert os.environ["PATH"].split(os.pathsep)[0] == str(bin_dir), (
"must be prepended — the copy we validated should win over a broken "
"system one"
)
def test_publishing_is_idempotent(monkeypatch, tmp_path):
"""It runs at import time; a reload or a second call must not grow PATH
without bound."""
bin_dir = tmp_path / "media"
bin_dir.mkdir()
(bin_dir / "ffmpeg").write_text("")
monkeypatch.setattr(ffmpeg_utils, "find_ffmpeg", lambda: str(bin_dir / "ffmpeg"))
monkeypatch.setattr(ffmpeg_utils, "find_ffprobe", lambda: None)
monkeypatch.setenv("PATH", "/usr/bin")
ffmpeg_utils.ensure_media_tools_on_path()
first = os.environ["PATH"]
assert ffmpeg_utils.ensure_media_tools_on_path() == []
assert os.environ["PATH"] == first
def test_separate_directories_are_both_added(monkeypatch, tmp_path):
"""A system ffmpeg plus a bundled ffprobe is a real configuration — the
resolver already supports it, so PATH must reflect both."""
a, b = tmp_path / "a", tmp_path / "b"
a.mkdir()
b.mkdir()
(a / "ffmpeg").write_text("")
(b / "ffprobe").write_text("")
monkeypatch.setattr(ffmpeg_utils, "find_ffmpeg", lambda: str(a / "ffmpeg"))
monkeypatch.setattr(ffmpeg_utils, "find_ffprobe", lambda: str(b / "ffprobe"))
monkeypatch.setenv("PATH", "/usr/bin")
assert sorted(ffmpeg_utils.ensure_media_tools_on_path()) == sorted([str(a), str(b)])
def test_nothing_resolvable_is_a_no_op(monkeypatch):
"""A machine with no media engine at all must still boot — the classified
error above is what that user gets, not a startup crash."""
monkeypatch.setattr(ffmpeg_utils, "find_ffmpeg", lambda: None)
monkeypatch.setattr(ffmpeg_utils, "find_ffprobe", lambda: None)
monkeypatch.setenv("PATH", "/usr/bin")
assert ffmpeg_utils.ensure_media_tools_on_path() == []
assert os.environ["PATH"] == "/usr/bin"
def test_a_raising_resolver_never_breaks_startup(monkeypatch):
def boom():
raise RuntimeError("media_tools registry unreadable")
monkeypatch.setattr(ffmpeg_utils, "find_ffmpeg", boom)
monkeypatch.setattr(ffmpeg_utils, "find_ffprobe", boom)
monkeypatch.setenv("PATH", "/usr/bin")
assert ffmpeg_utils.ensure_media_tools_on_path() == []
def test_a_path_that_merely_ends_in_the_tool_name_is_not_a_missing_tool(tmp_path):
"""Review finding (#1256): the match accepted any message ending in
'ffmpeg'/'ffprobe', so a missing FILE whose name happens to be the tool's
was handed the "repair your media engine" remedy.
Paths are built from `tmp_path` rather than written as literals — they are
only error-message data here, but a hardcoded /tmp trips Ruff S108."""
paths = [
str(tmp_path / "ffmpeg"),
str(tmp_path / "sub" / "ffprobe"),
"C:\\work\\ffmpeg",
]
for path in paths:
assert classify(f"[Errno 2] No such file or directory: {path}") != (
"MEDIA_TOOL_MISSING"
), path
def test_the_published_paths_are_not_logged(monkeypatch, tmp_path, caplog):
"""Review finding (#1256): a user-set FFMPEG_PATH resolves under their home
directory, and absolute home paths must not reach the log."""
import logging
bin_dir = tmp_path / "Users" / "alice" / "media"
bin_dir.mkdir(parents=True)
(bin_dir / "ffmpeg").write_text("")
monkeypatch.setattr(ffmpeg_utils, "find_ffmpeg", lambda: str(bin_dir / "ffmpeg"))
monkeypatch.setattr(ffmpeg_utils, "find_ffprobe", lambda: None)
monkeypatch.setenv("PATH", "/usr/bin")
with caplog.at_level(logging.INFO, logger="omnivoice.api"):
ffmpeg_utils.ensure_media_tools_on_path()
assert str(bin_dir) not in caplog.text
assert "alice" not in caplog.text