Files
VoiceStudio/tests/test_engine_routing.py
T
Palash DebnathandClaude Opus 4.8 2a1c3eee3d feat(routing): synth-time no-silent-fallback gating at all TTS entry points (#21 follow-up) (#440)
Closes the last #21 gap: a per-request engine=/model= override bypasses the
/engines/select host-gate, so an engine that can't use this host's GPU could
still be triggered at synth time and silently fall back to CPU (or die mid-
synth). Now enforced at every TTS synth entry point, reusing the SAME probe +
resolver — never re-deriving routing.

Shared helpers (services/engine_routing.py):
- `routing_notice(result)` → (status, reason) to surface, or None. Fires for
  cpu_fallback (always) and accelerated-with-caveat (driver/arch); silent for
  cpu_only / clean-accelerated / n/a.
- `header_safe_reason(reason)` → scrubbed + ASCII-sanitized (headers are
  latin-1; a non-ASCII device name would 500 otherwise) + ≤256 chars. No regex.

Entry points:
- REST `POST /generate` (generation.py): after engine resolution, resolve
  routing once; `unavailable` → 400; cpu_fallback / accelerated-caveat → 200 +
  `X-OmniVoice-Routing` + `X-OmniVoice-Routing-Reason` headers on the WAV
  StreamingResponse; benign → no headers. Covers OmniVoice + adapter branches.
- OpenAI-compat `POST /v1/audio/speech` (openai_compat.py): same gate + same
  headers; the tts-1/tts-1-hd alias inherits the active engine's routing.
- WebSocket `/ws/tts` (tts_stream.py): no headers → frames. `unavailable` →
  `{"type":"error",...}` + skip stream; cpu_fallback / caveat → one
  `{"type":"routing","status","reason"}` frame before any audio.
- `select_engine` response now echoes routing_status / effective_device /
  routing_reason (PR #432 added the gate; this adds the fields so the UI can
  warn on a cpu_fallback pick). New fields on SelectEngineResponse.

Frontend: `useTTS` reads the X-OmniVoice-Routing header and shows a one-time,
non-blocking toast (in-memory de-dup by status — a 50-clip batch fires once,
no localStorage). i18n keys `tts.routingFallback`/`tts.routingCaveat`.

Tests: routing_notice + header_safe_reason (ASCII/length/scrub) unit tests;
REST synth gate (unavailable→400, cpu_fallback→headers, cpu_only→none) via the
fake-engine harness with a mocked host; select response routing fields.

Deferred (small follow-up): dub-pipeline ASR routing note on the preflight_error
SSE channel — separate path, not a TTS synth entry point. No frontend /ws/tts
client exists today (the routing frame serves external API consumers).

Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-06-14 11:18:37 +05:30

173 lines
7.4 KiB
Python

"""Unit tests for backend/services/engine_routing.py (GPU compat matrix, PR 1).
``resolve_routing`` is a pure function over ``(gpu_compat, HostCaps)`` — these
tests construct ``HostCaps`` directly (no torch) and assert every rule + edge
from spec §2, plus the cross-OS determinism + never-emits-"n/a" guarantees.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
from core.device_caps import DIRECTML_MARKER, KERNEL_RISK_MARKER, HostCaps
from services.engine_routing import (
resolve_routing,
routing_notice,
header_safe_reason,
)
def _caps(family, *, notes=(), available=None):
if available is None:
available = (family, "cpu") if family != "cpu" else ("cpu",)
return HostCaps(family=family, available_families=available, notes=tuple(notes))
# ── Rule 2: accelerated ──────────────────────────────────────────────────
def test_cuda_host_cuda_engine_accelerated():
r = resolve_routing(("cuda", "cpu"), _caps("cuda"))
assert r == {"effective_device": "cuda", "routing_status": "accelerated",
"routing_reason": None}
def test_mps_host_mps_engine_accelerated():
r = resolve_routing(("mps", "cpu"), _caps("mps"))
assert r["routing_status"] == "accelerated"
assert r["effective_device"] == "mps"
def test_accelerated_with_kernel_risk_caveat():
note = f"GPU (sm_120) not in this torch build's archs — {KERNEL_RISK_MARKER}"
r = resolve_routing(("cuda", "cpu"), _caps("cuda", notes=[note]))
assert r["routing_status"] == "accelerated"
assert r["routing_reason"] is not None
assert r["routing_reason"].startswith("CUDA selected, but:")
assert KERNEL_RISK_MARKER in r["routing_reason"]
def test_accelerated_ignores_advisory_notes():
# Multi-GPU / VRAM advisory notes must NOT downgrade the accelerated badge.
r = resolve_routing(("cuda", "cpu"),
_caps("cuda", notes=["3 GPUs detected; routing reflects device 0"]))
assert r["routing_status"] == "accelerated"
assert r["routing_reason"] is None
# ── Rule 3: cpu_fallback (the no-silent-fallback signal) ──────────────────
def test_cuda_host_cpu_only_engine_falls_back():
r = resolve_routing(("cpu",), _caps("cuda"))
assert r["routing_status"] == "cpu_fallback"
assert r["effective_device"] == "cpu"
assert "no CUDA path" in r["routing_reason"]
def test_rocm_host_cuda_only_engine_falls_back_with_specific_reason():
r = resolve_routing(("cuda", "cpu"), _caps("rocm"))
assert r["routing_status"] == "cpu_fallback"
assert r["routing_reason"] == "declares CUDA only; ROCm not in its compat set"
def test_xpu_host_cpu_engine_falls_back():
r = resolve_routing(("cuda", "cpu"), _caps("xpu"))
assert r["routing_status"] == "cpu_fallback"
assert "no XPU path" in r["routing_reason"]
# ── Rule 4: cpu_only (benign) ─────────────────────────────────────────────
def test_cpu_host_cpu_engine_is_neutral():
r = resolve_routing(("cuda", "cpu"), _caps("cpu"))
assert r == {"effective_device": "cpu", "routing_status": "cpu_only",
"routing_reason": None}
def test_directml_host_gets_explanatory_reason_but_stays_neutral():
note = f"{DIRECTML_MARKER} (Windows GPU); torch-family probe treats as non-accelerated"
r = resolve_routing(("cuda", "cpu"), _caps("cpu", notes=[note]))
assert r["routing_status"] == "cpu_only" # never blocks
assert "DirectML" in r["routing_reason"]
# ── Rule 5: unavailable ───────────────────────────────────────────────────
def test_cpu_host_gpu_only_engine_unavailable():
r = resolve_routing(("cuda",), _caps("cpu"))
assert r["routing_status"] == "unavailable"
assert r["effective_device"] == "cuda"
assert "requires cuda" in r["routing_reason"]
assert "this host has cpu" in r["routing_reason"]
def test_xpu_host_gpu_only_no_cpu_unavailable():
r = resolve_routing(("cuda", "mps"), _caps("xpu"))
assert r["routing_status"] == "unavailable"
# ── Rule 1: defensive empty compat ────────────────────────────────────────
def test_empty_compat_is_defensive_cpu_only():
r = resolve_routing((), _caps("cuda"))
assert r["routing_status"] == "cpu_only"
assert r["effective_device"] == "cpu"
# ── Contract guarantees ───────────────────────────────────────────────────
def test_never_emits_n_a():
for fam in ("cuda", "rocm", "mps", "xpu", "cpu"):
for compat in ((), ("cpu",), ("cuda",), ("cuda", "cpu"), ("mps", "cpu")):
assert resolve_routing(compat, _caps(fam))["routing_status"] != "n/a"
def test_deterministic_across_calls():
caps = _caps("rocm")
assert resolve_routing(("cuda", "cpu"), caps) == resolve_routing(("cuda", "cpu"), caps)
def test_reason_str_for_fallback_and_unavailable_none_for_clean():
assert resolve_routing(("cpu",), _caps("cuda"))["routing_reason"] is not None
assert resolve_routing(("cuda",), _caps("cpu"))["routing_reason"] is not None
assert resolve_routing(("cuda", "cpu"), _caps("cuda"))["routing_reason"] is None
# ── routing_notice (synth-time surfacing decision) ──────────────────────────
def test_notice_emitted_for_cpu_fallback():
r = resolve_routing(("cpu",), _caps("cuda"))
n = routing_notice(r)
assert n is not None and n[0] == "cpu_fallback" and n[1]
def test_notice_emitted_for_accelerated_with_caveat():
note = f"sm_120 not in build — {KERNEL_RISK_MARKER}"
r = resolve_routing(("cuda", "cpu"), _caps("cuda", notes=[note]))
n = routing_notice(r)
assert n is not None and n[0] == "accelerated"
def test_no_notice_for_clean_accelerated_or_cpu_only():
assert routing_notice(resolve_routing(("cuda", "cpu"), _caps("cuda"))) is None
assert routing_notice(resolve_routing(("cuda", "cpu"), _caps("cpu"))) is None
# ── header_safe_reason (latin-1/length/scrub safety) ────────────────────────
def test_header_reason_none_for_empty():
assert header_safe_reason(None) is None
assert header_safe_reason("") is None
def test_header_reason_strips_non_ascii():
# Latin-1 accents + em-dash — all non-ASCII, must be stripped (no CJK so the
# hardcoded-CJK guard stays out of it).
out = header_safe_reason("CUDA on café — dríver naïve")
assert out == out.encode("ascii").decode("ascii") # round-trips as pure ASCII
assert "é" not in out and "—" not in out
def test_header_reason_strips_control_chars_no_header_injection():
# A CR/LF (or tab) must never survive into a header value.
out = header_safe_reason("ok\r\nX-Injected: evil\tmore")
assert "\r" not in out and "\n" not in out and "\t" not in out
assert "X-Injected" in out # text remains; only the control chars are gone
def test_header_reason_capped_at_256():
assert len(header_safe_reason("x" * 500)) == 256
def test_header_reason_scrubs_home_path():
out = header_safe_reason("failed at /home/alice/model")
assert "/home/alice" not in out and "~" in out